Maya a1 changes answers when options are reordered

If you use Maya a1 for multiple-choice tasks, option order matters: the model selected a different answer in 25.8 percent of 951 tested questions.

Maya a1 changes answers when options are reordered

Key points

  • The tested Maya a1 checkpoint has 421 million parameters.
  • Reordering answer choices changed Maya a1's response in 25.8 percent of cases, with a confidence interval from 22.9 to 28.7 percent.
  • The checkpoint uses a two-layer option head without positional data and scores each option through a separate hidden state.

Context

The study looked into whether Maya a1 relies on an option's content or its position when picking an answer. It shuffled answer choices and used six random orders for questions with twelve options, showing significant order sensitivity in the tested checkpoint. For developers and technical decision-makers, this makes testing option-order variation crucial when validating model-dependent workflows.

What this means for you

Directly applicable

You can add option-order variations to acceptance tests for model-dependent workflows and use the results when assessing answer reliability.

Who benefits: Developers and technical decision-makers who evaluate multiple-choice model features or select models for enterprise workflows.

Share article:

Does a report affect your system?

Send the link to the report and two sentences about your system. You get an assessment of whether action is needed and what the fix looks like.